“I think I will win the Ballon D’or one day. I was happy when they sacked Erik ten Hag. He was not playing me the right way. But I will show the fans that I am on our next match under Rúben Amorim. He is my type of coach.”-BREAKING NEWS: Antony promises Manchester United fans that he will be back to scoring under Rúben Amorim and why he has been under-performing
Antony’s Rollercoaster Ride at Manchester United: A Tale of Promise, Struggles, and Uncertainty
When Antony scored 35 minutes into his Manchester United debut, fans were optimistic that Erik ten Hag’s €95 million signing from Ajax had delivered a solution to the team’s long-standing issues on the flanks. His electrifying performance in a 3-1 victory over Arsenal hinted at a bright future, especially following Jadon Sancho’s struggles.
Antony’s initial impact, including goals against Manchester City and Everton, showcased his potential. However, the promise of his early performances has faded over time, leaving fans questioning whether he can meet the expectations tied to his hefty transfer fee.
From Dream Start to Diminished Returns
Despite an impressive start, Antony’s form has nosedived. Over two seasons, he has managed only nine goals in 81 appearances, a meager return for a player of his price tag. This season, his lone goal came from the penalty spot in a Carabao Cup thrashing of Barnsley.
His first season’s eight goals were dismissed as an adjustment period, but his inability to evolve and unpredictable performances have led to frustration. Once a key player, Antony now faces competition and a precarious position in the squad.
A Controversial Transfer
Antony’s move from Ajax to United was fraught with controversy. In 2022, he refused to play for Ajax, citing a lack of focus, to force the transfer. Ajax manager Alfred Schreuder criticized Antony for prioritizing financial incentives over loyalty, raising early concerns about his character under pressure—concerns that now echo in his struggles at United.
Tactical Challenges
Antony’s one-dimensional style, heavily reliant on his left foot and predictable inside cuts, has been exposed in the Premier League’s high-intensity environment. While ten Hag hoped his familiarity with Ajax’s system would ease the transition, Antony’s limitations have made him easy to defend against.
The arrival of Ruben Amorim as manager could offer a lifeline. Amorim’s adaptable tactics might help Antony diversify his game. However, if Antony fails to improve, his weaknesses could become even more apparent under a manager intent on revitalizing the squad.
Mental and Cultural Adjustments
Antony’s struggles may also stem from adapting to England’s culture and footballing demands. His tumultuous Ajax exit hinted at difficulty handling adversity, a challenge magnified under Manchester United’s immense scrutiny.
His performances often wilt under pressure, raising questions about his mental resilience. For Antony, rediscovering confidence and focus will be crucial to turning his fortunes around.
What Lies Ahead?
Antony’s future at United remains uncertain. To secure his place, he must:
1. Diversify his playstyle: Develop his right foot, unpredictability, and decision-making.
2. Embrace competition: Take every chance to excel under Amorim’s new system.
3. Show resilience: Overcome criticism and prove he can thrive under pressure.
If Antony fails to adapt, a move away from Old Trafford might be his best option, with European clubs or a return to Brazil offering opportunities for a fresh start.
Lessons from a High-Profile Signing
Antony’s transfer has underscored the pitfalls of inflated expectations and reckless spending. His struggles highlight the need for better alignment between recruitment, tactical fit, and long-term planning—a point emphasized by Sir Jim Ratcliffe’s critique of United’s recent transfer history.
The Defining Moment
Antony still has a chance to rewrite his story. Whether his journey ends in redemption or departure, his fate will be a pivotal subplot in Manchester United’s efforts to rebuild and reclaim their footballing dominance. For now, Antony’s response will determine his future. The ball, as always, is in his court.
