Manchester United’s decision to sell Scott McTominay could become one of the club’s most debated transfer decisions, with reports suggesting that the club’s ownership may now be questioning whether allowing the midfielder to leave Old Trafford was the right move.
McTominay departed Manchester United in the summer of 2024 to join Italian side Napoli after struggling to establish himself as an undisputed starter in the Premier League. However, his performances in Italy have demonstrated his quality, physical strength and ability to influence important matches.
The Scottish international spent several years at Manchester United after progressing through the club’s academy. During his time at Old Trafford, he became known for his determination, work rate, powerful runs into the penalty area and ability to score important goals.
Although McTominay was not always guaranteed a starting position, he regularly demonstrated his commitment whenever he was given an opportunity.
His departure was initially viewed by some supporters as a reasonable decision because Manchester United were looking to reshape their midfield and generate funds for new signings.
However, his impressive development at Napoli has encouraged many United supporters to question whether the club made a mistake by allowing him to leave.
McTominay quickly adapted to Italian football and became an influential figure in Napoli’s midfield. His physical presence, attacking movement and ability to arrive in dangerous positions have made him an important player.
His performances have also demonstrated that he possesses qualities that could have been useful to Manchester United, particularly during matches when the team struggles to control the midfield.
The Red Devils have experienced several midfield challenges, with supporters regularly demanding more energy, physicality and consistency from the players operating in that department.
McTominay’s ability to contribute defensively while also supporting attacking movements could have provided United with another valuable option.
His goalscoring ability is another quality that Manchester United might now appreciate. Unlike traditional defensive midfielders, the Scottish international has repeatedly shown that he can make intelligent runs into the opposition penalty area and convert opportunities.
Meanwhile, Napoli have benefited from having a midfielder who understands how to contribute in different areas of the pitch.
There is also growing discussion among supporters about whether Manchester United should consider bringing McTominay back to Old Trafford in a future transfer window.
However, such a move would depend on Napoli’s willingness to negotiate and the financial demands involved in securing his services.
Manchester United must also consider whether re-signing a former player would represent the best use of their transfer budget, especially with other areas of the squad requiring attention.
For the club’s supporters, McTominay’s situation is another reminder that players sometimes need the right environment and regular opportunities to demonstrate their full potential.
His departure was not necessarily an unpopular decision at the time, but his subsequent performances have changed the conversation surrounding the transfer.
For now, there is no verified public statement confirming that Manchester United’s owner has admitted regretting the sale. Nevertheless, the debate surrounding McTominay’s departure continues.
The Scottish midfielder remains a player many United supporters would welcome back, and his success in Italy has ensured that his name continues to attract attention at Old Trafford.